Local Pediatricians Advocate Later School Start Times—
Thursday, March 02, 2017 11:58 AM
As pediatricians and parents, we, of the Department of Pediatrics at Pen Bay Medical Center, would like to offer our full support to moving the school start time for middle school and high school students back. We recognize that school start times are set as a balance between a large array of factors. This letter serves to highlight some of the research, taken from the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) 2014 published report on school start times, on the impact of later sleep times on middle and high school students.
1) Why do teens go to sleep later and how much sleep do they need?
Several studies have demonstrated that most teenagers need 8.5 to 9.5 hours of sleep per night. The time children fall asleep is the result of biologic processes and social obligations which minimize the opportunities for adolescents to sleep. With the onset of puberty most adolescents begin to shift fall-asleep time by up to two hours. This “phase shift” occurs due to later nocturnal secretion of the hormone melatonin which plays a major role in sleep regulation. This results in a preference of falling asleep later. In addition, an adolescent takes longer to feel tired, compared to prepubertal children, which also contributes to transition to sleep. In a poll performed by the National Sleep Foundation, 59 percent of sixth- through eighth-graders and 87 percent of high school students did not get the recommended amount of sleep.
2) Would students get more sleep if school times moved back or just go to bed later?
There is strong evidence that when middle and high schools delay start time students obtain more sleep. In the 1997–1998 school year the city of Minneapolis shifted high school start times from 7:15 a.m. to 8:40 a.m. Bedtimes did not shift after the change and students obtained nearly one additional hour of sleep on school nights. In another study when school start times were shifted one hour later, the percentage of children getting greater than eight hours of sleep increased from 37 percent to 50 percent. A separate study looking at more than 9,000 students from eight public high schools from three states demonstrated that the percentage of children sleeping greater than eight hours was dramatically higher in schools with later start times (33 percent at 7:30 a.m. vs. 66 percent at 8:55 a.m.).
3) What are the school-based benefits of later start times?
A number of studies have clearly demonstrated that delaying start times has a significant positive effect on key outcomes. In the Minneapolis study, the attendance rates of students in grades 9 to 11 improved. Another research group found that moving sleep back by one hour could have an impact on standardized test scores as much as reducing class size by one-third. In the three-state study referenced above, five of the six schools involved showed a significant increase in grade point average in math, English, science and social studies.
4) What are the impacts on overall health?
There is mounting evidence that increased sleep leads to reduced problems with mood. In a study of children with later sleep times, the rate of self-reported depression fell and motivation improved following the change in school start times. The rate of car accidents in 17- to 18-year-old students fell by 16.5 percent after delay in school start time. Whereas a study conducted for the same time, in a location with early start times, saw a 7.8 percent increase in car accident rates.
Dr. William Stephenson, Dr. Dana Goldsmith, Dr. Peter Vickerman, Dr. Adeline Winkes, Pen Bay Pediatrics, Rockport